A Major Decision: Passion, Practicality and Profession
Whether they aspire to walk on the moon, live in a castle or fly planes, children often dream about their future occupation. Years later, as they enter college, those visions have generally shifted. For some, the realization that they cannot breathe in space changes their plans; for others, their interests simply mature. Some find that their ambitions collide with the harsh realities of the job market. At Yeshiva University, students’ choices of majors reflect a balance between personal motivation and practical career considerations. Drawing on enrollment data and faculty perspectives, this article asks how views of the job market may be shaping students’ decisions to pursue STEM, business or the humanities.
According to Yeshiva University’s Office of Institutional Research and Assessment, students’ choices of majors differ between Wilf and Beren campuses. On the Beren campus, biology and psychology are consistently the two most popular majors, each accounting for approximately 15-20% of students. On the Wilf campus, by contrast, approximately 7% of students major in biology and another 7% in psychology. Meanwhile, the Sy Syms School of Business has grown substantially across both campuses. On the Beren campus, from Fall 2021 to Spring 2026, enrollment increased from 173 students to 241 students; on the Wilf campus, Sy Syms enrollment increased from 530 students to 705 students in these years, adding 57 students from Fall 2024 to Spring 2026 alone.
The growth of Sy Syms School of Business offers an opportunity to examine why YU students are increasingly drawn to degrees in business. Talia Siegel (SSSB ‘28), a junior studying marketing on the Beren campus, shared with The Commentator, “I always thought that a career in business was better suited for me, and I have had an interest in marketing and public relations. As I explore it more now, I love it and find it very fulfilling.” In her experience, exploring business as a whole has granted her the opportunity to discover her more specific career interests.
Dr. Elad Granot, Undergraduate Dean of the Sy Syms School of Business, emphasized that within business, “students can study finance, accounting, marketing, analytics, entrepreneurship, strategy, and other disciplines…[which] are enormously attractive to an ambitious generation.” In Granot’s view, this breadth of options may be what draws more students to business-oriented careers. But if business has long offered diverse career opportunities, why are more students choosing to pursue it now? According to Granot, “The boundaries between industries are disappearing…Business provides a language for operating across all of those worlds.” As technology, healthcare and finance increasingly intersect, business education may appeal to students seeking flexibility across industries and career paths.
While business enrollment has grown, the humanities have not experienced comparable growth. Specifically, on the Wilf campus, the english major enrollment has decreased minimally from 14 to 10 students from Fall 2021 to Spring 2026, with little fluctuation. Similarly, on the Beren campus, the enrollment has slightly increased from 17 students in Fall 2021 to 20 students in Spring 2026. Dr. Nora Nachumi, chair of Stern College’s english department, observed that students and their families increasingly prioritize degrees associated with practical, job-specific skills. She noted that this trend has coincided with greater enthusiasm for fields such as business, computer science, engineering and health care. Still, students who choose english often do so because they value the intellectual exploration the discipline offers. Nachumi explained that english majors “love entering new worlds, stretching their imaginations, communication and critical thinking.” Although english and other humanities disciplines cultivate transferable skills, concerns about career prospects may discourage students from pursuing subjects that interest them. On the Wilf campus, for example, a combined 5% of students major in political science, English and History. These figures raise an important question: To what extent do students’ academic choices reflect their personal interests, and to what extent are they shaped by their perceptions of what they believe they should study?
The large portion of biology and psychology majors on the Beren campus offers an interesting perspective. Together these majors account for approximately one-third of Beren campus students’ declared majors, reflecting sustained interest in the sciences and human behavior. Dr. Alyssa Schuck, chair of Stern College’s biology department, explained that many biology majors intend to pursue careers in healthcare. She emphasized, however, that career preparation is not the only motivation: “At the same time, many of these pre-health students are drawn to biology simply because they find the subject fascinating.” Biology therefore illustrates how personal curiosity and professional goals can reinforce one another. Some students may be attracted to the scientific rigor of the discipline, the opportunity to investigate complex questions or the prospect of a career in healthcare. Regardless, its continued popularity suggests that students do not necessarily have to choose between studying what they love and preparing for their futures.
This is true as long as their interests happen to align with reliable career options. For students whose passions lie elsewhere, the choice may feel far less harmonious. Gaby Zlatin (SCW ‘29) is one such student. Gaby explained, “I would love to be an art major because I really enjoy my classes and the creativity. Realistically, I cannot be an artist as a career, so I am studying psychology and hope to implement art as a smaller piece of my job.” While Gaby hopes to find a balance between her personal interests and professional motivations, unfortunately, many students completely abandon their creative desires when choosing areas of study in favor of a practical career.
As children grow up, their visions of the future begin to meet the realities of the professional world. Students must learn to balance their passions with the opportunities and limitations around them. At YU, the growth of Sy Syms suggests the appeal of a field offering flexibility across industries, while the limited representation of humanities majors raises questions about how career expectations influence students’ academic choices. For students studying biology, meanwhile, personal fascination and professional preparation may go hand in hand. Together, these trends reveal the different ways students balance their interests with their expectations of future success.
At YU, regardless of their majors or career paths, students dedicate hours to studying Jewish studies. While students’ choices in secular studies may be influenced by career prospects and the realities of the job market, Judaic studies offers another avenue of exploration that is not necessarily driven by professional goals. Students have the opportunity to pursue learning for its own sake. In balancing secular and Judaic studies, students’ academic pursuits reflect not only what they hope to do in the future, but also the values they seek to represent. Ultimately, choosing a major is more than just the careers students choose; it is about the interests they have, the values they prioritize and what kind of future to build.
Photo Caption: Various textbooks
Photo Credit: Wikimedia Commons